Showing posts with the label BayesianShow all

Anthropic reasoning 2: the merciful Dr. Killian.

In part 1, I argued that taking your own existence as a datum is coherent and, at least in some situations, necessary. To show that, I gave a simple barebones example of Dr. Killian, who flips a coin and, if it lands tails, kills you in your sleep. If you then wake up … Read more

The ensemble technique: how to easily handle tricky probability puzzles with 5th grade math.

There are some fun and tricky puzzles with probability, like the famous Monty Hall problem, where sometimes even professional mathematicians get confused. But there is one easy "hack" to quickly solving even the most bizarre such conundrums, the ensemble tech… Read more

The lottery fallacy.

Understanding common logical fallacies is really helpful to quickly put your finger on the exact flaw in a fishy argument. But sometimes fallacies themselves can trick you, and you can end up committing the fallacy fallacy by accusing someone of a fallacy who isn't… Read more

A fish named Asha: foiling an attack on the Requirement of Total Evidence.

An interesting challenge to the Requirement of Total Evidence is posed by philosopher Peter Epstein in his 2016 paper  The Fine-tuning Argument and the Requirement of Total Evidence . He gives a simple scenario that, he argues, disproves it. First, what is this Require… Read more

Anthropic reasoning 1: I am, therefore I think.

Should you use the mere fact of your own existence as a significant piece of information in your reasoning? Or is it, in and of itself, without any actual specifics, completely vacuous or even incoherent? To explain what I mean, here's a concrete example.  Abiogene… Read more

An atom named Fred: defending the total evidence requirement principle.

Warning: this particular article is going to be quite a bit more incomprehensible than my other articles. It is part of a discussion Alex Popescu, I, and a poster that goes by Disagreeable Me have been having on some tricky aspects of probabilistic inferences, particul… Read more

Fine-tuning and the multiverse: shorter and sweeter.

Is fine-tuning evidence of the multiverse? I argue that no, but paradoxically the inference to the multiverse may still be valid. All of the background is in my main multiverse article , but this one is still pretty self-contained. You actually don't even need to k… Read more