Showing posts with the label deconstructionShow all

The category mistake: useful but tricky.

In the recent article about the lottery fallacy  I talked about how to spot this fallacy but also how not to "overspot" it and start seeing it even if it's not there. Let's do the same with the fallacy known as the category mistake or category error .… Read more

Just semantics?

In a recent article on free will I argued that there are, very broadly speaking, two candidate meanings for the term "free will". I ended the article by asking: which of the two definitions is better? But what does it even mean for one definition of a term t… Read more

A response to "Solution to the Mutant Liar"

This is a response article to a post by my colleague Dmitriy titled   Solution to the Mutant Liar . In a previous article, ReasonMeThis (aka Dmitriy) laid out a two-part solution for circumventing the liar sentence paradox ("this sentence is false" and simila… Read more

Solution to the Mutant Liar.

In the previous installment , I told you about the Mutant Ninja Liar's Paradox. I didn't tell you my solution to it though. I will do that here but be warned: you will probably enjoy it more if you have already spent some time trying to figure out the paradox o… Read more

The paradox that broke my brain.

I first learned about the basic version of the Liar's Paradox - "This statement is false" - when I was about 13 and thought it was the silliest thing. I thought I quickly solved it and there was nothing remotely complicated or interesting about it and con… Read more

If you are a machine, do you have free will?

If the laws of nature say that everything is determined, does that mean there is no free will? It might seem to you that the answer is clearly no - if everything, including your brain, follows some set of unalterable rules, then you are not free, not in control of your… Read more

The lottery fallacy.

Understanding common logical fallacies is really helpful to quickly put your finger on the exact flaw in a fishy argument. But sometimes fallacies themselves can trick you, and you can end up committing the fallacy fallacy by accusing someone of a fallacy who isn't… Read more

Shouting "fire" in a Crowder theater.

Some people say that the United States is the only country that has freedom of speech. An example of such people would be the popular conservative personality Steven Crowder. His argument (which you can hear in the video below) is based on the fact that other countries… Read more

Fine-tuning, multiverse, and monkeys with typewriters.

Many prominent physicists believe that fine-tuning implies the existence of a vast number of different universes, many theologians believe it implies God. Others say that it implies neither and that everyone else is just being silly. Two opposing views were recently p… Read more