Showing posts with the label anthropicShow all

The repugnant conclusion.

This paradox in ethics is called the repugnant conclusion . Many people would agree with the following when it comes to designing a policy that affects people's quality of life and the size of the population. A world with 10bln people and high happiness for each is… Read more

Could we be living in a simulation, or does physics rule that out?

There's an argument, due to philosopher Nick Bostrom, that under some not-too-wild assumptions it's likely that we are living in a computer simulation. The simulation argument and its provocative conclusion has some high-profile supporters, such as Neil DeGras… Read more

Anthropic reasoning 2: the merciful Dr. Killian.

In part 1, I argued that taking your own existence as a datum is coherent and, at least in some situations, necessary. To show that, I gave a simple barebones example of Dr. Killian, who flips a coin and, if it lands tails, kills you in your sleep. If you then wake up … Read more

Bostrom's Incubator and the epistemic ensemble.

A lot of tricky problems involving probabilities, such as the famous Monty Hall problem that has lead astray even professional statisticians, can be solved quickly and painlessly with the ensemble method ( see how ). The question however is: is the ensemble method alwa… Read more

Anthropic reasoning 1: I am, therefore I think.

Should you use the mere fact of your own existence as a significant piece of information in your reasoning? Or is it, in and of itself, without any actual specifics, completely vacuous or even incoherent? To explain what I mean, here's a concrete example.  Abiogene… Read more

Fine-tuning and the multiverse: shorter and sweeter.

Is fine-tuning evidence of the multiverse? I argue that no, but paradoxically the inference to the multiverse may still be valid. All of the background is in my main multiverse article , but this one is still pretty self-contained. You actually don't even need to k… Read more

Are you a Boltzmann brain?

Have you ever wondered: what if everything I see around me is just an illusion, a dream? This might sound like a silly possibility that only a child or a philosopher would seriously entertain, but I want to show you it's far more serious than that. In fact, in some… Read more

Fine-tuning, multiverse, and monkeys with typewriters.

Many prominent physicists believe that fine-tuning implies the existence of a vast number of different universes, many theologians believe it implies God. Others say that it implies neither and that everyone else is just being silly. Two opposing views were recently p… Read more